West Bengal Finance Minister Amit Mitra lashed out at the planning of execution of the GST and asserted that hawala transactions have expanded because of the disappointment of the GST's automated digitized process. The pastor's cases accept essentialness as there have been reports of taking off stores by Indians in Swiss banks. "As indicated by the plan of the circuitous tax framework, GSTR 1, which is a shape to be filled and uplinked, speaks to deals esteem figures while GSTR 2 shapes, which speak to buy figures, are self-populated. GSTR 3B, a short shape, was presented and that frame was not supported by invoices," Mitra, who is an individual from the GST Council, said at a Facebook Live on the event of one year of the GST take off in the nation.
"Today a short (returns) form is being filled and when you do not upload invoices, according to me, today hawala is happening out of GST. If invoice is not required to be uploaded, when you file GSTR-3B then you claim input tax credit (ITC), which is black money because there was no transaction. It was unprepared GST,” Mitra said.
Under the GST regime, businesses currently file summary sales return GSTR-3B and final sales return GSTR-1. Initially when GST was implemented, businesses were required to fill up 3 forms- GSTR-1 (sales return), GSTR-2 (purchase return) and GSTR-3 (final return which combines both GSTR-1 and 2).
However, businesses complained of difficulties in filing of three returns a month as the GST systems could not accept the last minute rush on the due date of filing those returns. Following this, the GST Council, chaired by Union Finance Minister and comprising state finance ministers, decided to come out with a summary sales returns form GSTR-3B for businesses to pay taxes by the 20th day of the succeeding month.
"I had said that GST should not be launched on July 1, 2017. Computers were required to process 300 crore invoices, but there was no testing or pilot run," Mitra said. GST, which amalgamated 17 different central and state taxes including excise duty and sales tax or VAT, not just made India one market by levying a uniform tax rate on a good or service, it also did away with tax-on-tax prevalent in the previous system.
"We had asked for not to reveal the GST in July (2017), yet the Inside did not tune in. As an aftermath, the GSTN programming neglected to oversee such a large number of transactions," he said in the state Assembly today.
"Presently, a ton of organizations are recording returns physically on the grounds that the goods neglected to take the tremendous load. Thus, hawala transactions have gone up," he included.
The minister said that according to the plan of the new aberrant duty framework, GSTR 1 shapes speak to deals esteem figures, while GSTR 2 frames contain buy figures, and both are acting naturally populated.
Because of the defective execution of the Goods and Services Tax (GST), the states earned Rs 78,929 crore less income since July 2017, which has been remunerated by the Inside according to pay law of the new circuitous duty routine, he said.
India's Gross domestic goods development declined from 8.2 percent in 2015-16 to 7.1 percent in 2016-17 and further to 6.7 percent in 2017-18. The financial development is relied upon to enhance to 7.4 percent in the current monetary which closes in Walk 2019.
Mitra said that notwithstanding expending states are enduring income misfortune because of GST execution. Since there is no coordinating of invoices in GST, individuals are erroneously creating invoices and guaranteeing input to assess credit in filing GSTR-3B, prompting hawala transactions.