Purchase or Lease: Which is Favorable?


Factors in Deciding to Buy or Rent:

  • Consider financial stability, long-term plans, the local housing market, and personal preferences.
  • Evaluate the current and future financial situation and willingness to take on homeownership responsibilities.

Detailed Analysis in India (Considering Taxes):

  • For renting, calculate yearly rent expenses and potential rent increases due to inflation.
  • For buying with a loan, calculate monthly Equated Monthly Installment (EMI) covering interest, principal, insurance, and charges.
  • Compare yearly rent with annualized home loan EMI cost to understand financial implications.
  • Factor in rent changes and total homeownership cost for an informed decision.

Tax Benefits with Home Loans in India:

  • Self-occupied property: Deduct up to INR 2 lakhs/year on home loan interest (Section 24(b) of Income Tax Act).
  • Rented property: No limit on interest deduction, actual interest can be claimed.
  • Principal repayment deduction up to INR 1.5 lakhs/year (Section 80C).
  • Tax benefits impact overall tax liability, influencing buy-vs-rent choice.

Capital Gains Tax Implications on Property Sale:

  • Selling house owned over two years: 20% tax on long-term gains with indexation benefit.
  • Avoid tax by reinvesting sale proceeds in another property (Section 54 or 54F).
  • Renting property avoids capital gains tax on the sale.

Considerations for Affordability, Stability, and Lifestyle:

  • Assess financial health including income and savings.
  • Evaluate ability to handle down payment, EMIs, and homeownership expenses.
  • Think about property value growth over time and its impact on overall finances.
  • Consider future goals and lifestyle needs.
  • Buying offers stability but less flexibility; renting offers freedom without ownership duties.

let’s illustrate the points using an example:

Raj is a young professional working in Bengaluru, India. He’s contemplating whether he should buy a house or continue renting. Here’s how he considers his options:

1. Factors in Deciding:
Raj thinks about his stable job and his plan to settle down in the city for the foreseeable future. He considers the local housing market and whether he’s ready to take on the responsibilities of homeownership, like maintenance and repairs.

2. Detailed Analysis (Considering Taxes):
Raj decides to dig deeper. He calculates that his yearly rent would be around INR 3.6 lakhs if he continues renting. On the other hand, he’s considering a home loan for a property that would result in a monthly EMI of around INR 25,000.

Comparing these, he sees that his yearly rent expense would be higher than the annualized cost of the home loan EMI. But he also takes into account that rent might increase every year due to inflation, which could make renting even more expensive over time.

3. Tax Benefits with Home Loans:
Raj learns that if he buys a house with a home loan, he can get tax benefits. Let’s say the interest he pays in a year is around INR 2.5 lakhs. He can claim up to INR 2 lakhs of that as a deduction. Additionally, he can get a deduction of up to INR 1.5 lakhs for the principal repayment. This knowledge helps Raj see how these tax benefits could impact his overall financial situation.

4. Capital Gains Tax Implications:
Raj also thinks about the future. He considers what would happen if he decides to sell the property later. If he owns the property for more than two years and decides to sell it, he would have to pay a 20% tax on the profit he makes from the sale. However, he learns that he could avoid this tax if he reinvests the money from the sale into another property.

5. Considerations for Affordability, Stability, and Lifestyle:
Taking a step back, Raj evaluates his affordability. He looks at his income, savings, and the money he can put down as a down payment. He also weighs the possibility of the property’s value increasing over time.

He’s also thinking about his lifestyle goals. While he values the stability of owning a home, he realizes that he might want to explore job opportunities in other cities in the coming years. Renting gives him more flexibility in that regard.

After considering all these points, Raj decides that for his current situation, it might be more financially reasonable to buy a house. The tax benefits, the potential for property value growth, and his desire for stability align with his goals. However, he also acknowledges that circumstances could change, and he’s keeping in mind the potential changes in his life.

In essence, Raj has balanced his financial status, future aspirations, and personal preferences to make an informed decision that suits his situation.

If You have any queries then connect with us at [email protected] or [email protected] & contact us  & stay updated with our latest blogs & articles

Don't forget to share this article :-

Stay Updated With Our Blogs!

Explore more of our blogs to have better clarity and understanding
of the latest corporate & business updates.

Why People Choose Our Services ?

Free Legal Advice

We provide free of cost consultation and legal advice to our clients.

Tech Driven Platform

All our services are online no need you to travel from your place to get our services.

Grow your business

Experts Team

We are a team of more than 15+ professionals with 11 years of experience.

Transparent pricing

There are no hidden & extra charges* other than the quote/invoice we provide.

100 % Client Satisfaction

We aim that all our customers are fully satisfied with our services.

On-Time Delivery

We value your time and we promise all our services are delivered on time.

Why Trust legal Suvidha?

People Who loved our services and what they feel.

In this Journey of the past 10+ years, we had gained the trust of many startups, businesses, and professionals in India and stand with a 4.9/5 rating in google reviews.We register business online and save time & paperwork.

Reno K Subramaniam
Reno K Subramaniam
I have recently registered a Private Limited firm and was looking for a CA to take care of the filings, Startup India Certificate, and other formalities. I have received emails from legal Suvidha and a few others. I tried talking to them all. But, Mr. Mayank from Legal Suvidha was very impressive and was patient enough, prompt to answer all the queries. He has a very professional team and after the initial formalities, I started interacting with the team. It's not even 2 weeks but I really feel overwhelmed by their service and professionalism. I received my startup India certificate yesterday and my filings have been done promptly. The team at legal suvidha Ms. Nidhi, Ms. Priyanka, Ms. Koshika, and Ms. Saloni all show the same professionalism and are readily available to take care of the official filings and stuff. Overall a great experience till now and looking forward to a great journey!
pankaj tiwari
pankaj tiwari
Legal suvidha is a team of genuine and experienced professionals who give you best services according to your profile
Raman Krishnan
Raman Krishnan
Saloni from legalsuvidha has done a excellent job for filling and geting certificate of DPIIT. Thanks to legalsuvidha.
Prakaash Hari
Prakaash Hari
Team Legal Suvidha offers a brilliant service. There communication is quite clear and they execute the job meticulously. We are a startup private limited company and their advice is so critical in making my decision. Well done team. Keep it up. Prakaash Hari, Director, ipixela.
Priyanka Rudra
Priyanka Rudra
Dedicated team and fast response
Dr. Vishal Ghag
Dr. Vishal Ghag
Been using their services since 3 years now and I am absolutely happy with Legal Suvidha. They have been supportive, understanding and highly skilled at helping me with my business needs.

Our Partnerships & Collaborations

Contact us and grow your business

Legal Suvidha App

Now all Professional Services in a Single Click !

Now get all the services required for your business in a single app.

Subscribe to our newsletter & grow your business

Subscribe To Our Newsletter .

Sign up to receive email updates on new product announcements, special promotions, sales & more.